INSPIRE IVF Public Company LimitedSET: IVF🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Company places importance on having a good internal control system in accordance with good corporate governance principles, namely, having a transparent, fair, reliable, and accountable operating system with checks and balances. This will lead to the maximum benefit of shareholders, employees, customers, partners, and all stakeholders. As of September 30, 2024, the Company has an Audit Committee of 3 members, which is responsible for reviewing the adequacy of the Company's internal control system, including reviewing to ensure that the Company conducts business in accordance with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Public Limited Companies Act, the Securities and Exchange Act, or other regulations related to the Company and/or the Company's business.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 2/2024, held on March 17, 2024. All audit committee members attended the meeting. The Board of Directors considered and prepared an assessment of the adequacy of the Company's internal control system, covering all 5 components of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO), namely:

1. Control Environment

2. Risk Management

3. Control Activities

4. Information & Communication

5. Monitoring Activities

From considering the assessment of the adequacy of the Company's internal control system, the Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company has established management and internal control systems that are adequate and effective enough to prevent potential risks. There is also monitoring of operations to safeguard the Company's assets from unauthorized use by directors or management. Additionally, there are adequate internal controls regarding transactions with potentially conflicting individuals and related parties. The Board of Directors and management have encouraged employees throughout the organization to recognize the importance of internal control. Sufficient personnel have been allocated to ensure the adequacy and appropriateness of the Company's internal control system. This includes the ability to effectively modify and adapt to changing circumstances. This ensures that the Company's operations achieve their objectives, comply with relevant laws and regulations, and adhere to good corporate governance principles. The Company has established clear roles and responsibilities, including the establishment of appropriate written regulations, rules, policies, and authorization of operations. The Audit Committee has no dissenting opinions from the opinions of the Board of Directors.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)0040

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2023-012024-01
• Observations from the internal control system audit of each department within the company for the year 2023 and follow-up: 1. Laboratory and Inventory Management: In the system for recording incoming goods, the company had previously established guidelines for the receiving staff, which include 1) the nursing department (in the case of recording received medications and medical supplies) or 2) the laboratory department (in the case of recording received medical consumables and chemicals), to record the quantity received, lot number, and expiration date of the goods in the system. Subsequently, a goods receipt note is printed for signing according to the next steps. In the case of recording incoming goods for medical consumables where the manufacturer does not specify an expiration date, the receiving staff must enter the information into the system according to the specified format to enable the recording of the goods. However, it was found that the company did not completely record important information from the seller in the system when recording incoming goods. Specifically, there were 4 instances where the lot number was not recorded and 2 instances where the expiration date was not entered correctly according to the specified format. This was because these items were received from cash purchases where the finance department had access to the system for recording incoming goods using purchase orders/goods receipt notes. However, as the established work procedures did not cover the recording of incoming goods in such cases, the staff did not record the lot number and expiration date correctly according to the guidelines. Risk Level: Medium Risks and Impacts: - Failure to record the lot number or enter the expiration date correctly according to the guidelines may result in users of the goods information for picking and usage not adhering to the first-in, first-out inventory management principle. There is also a risk of using expired goods.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has improved the general procurement procedures by adding operational steps for ordering and receiving goods in all cases, including both credit purchases and cash purchases.

- Define clear and written criteria and conditions for data recording, such as data identification, product code, product name, lot number, and expiration date. Communicate these guidelines within the organization to ensure that all personnel are aware of and strictly adhere to them.

- During the monitoring period from November 2023 to January 2024, the company accurately recorded and entered data into the system in accordance with the established guidelines.

month/year Range2023-012024-01
• Observations from the internal control system audit for each department within the company for the year 2023 and follow-up 2. Laboratory and Inventory Management: The company has controls over the dispensing of medications for employee welfare benefits. However, these dispensations are not recorded in the system. This is because the company has not yet clearly separated the medication inventory in the system for customer service from the medication inventory for employee welfare benefits. Additionally, there is no clearly defined written procedure for recording the dispensing of medications for employee welfare benefits in the system. As a result, the nursing department only has control over the dispensing of medications through the monthly employee medication request forms.
Incident no longer subject to action

-   The company has improved its operational procedures for drug and medical supply management to clearly separate the management of drug inventory for customer service from the drug inventory provided for employee welfare.

-   For the drug inventory for customer service, there will be control and dispensing records in the system every time. As for the drug inventory for employee welfare, the nursing department will control and dispense the medication. The nursing department will control and record the dispensing of medication in the inventory movement control sheet and manage the drug inventory for employee welfare to be sufficient.

-  During the monitoring period from November 1966 to January 1967, the company's dispensing of medication, medication inventory control for employee welfare, and the preparation of medication dispensing summary reports were all in accordance with the established guidelines.

month/year Range2023-012024-01
• Observations from the Internal Control System Audit for Each Department in 2023 and Follow-up 3. Procurement, Expenses, and Payment: The company issued purchase orders (POs) with quantities exceeding those approved in the purchase requisitions (PRs) without providing justification. This was due to the vendor providing 10 units of the product as complimentary items with the purchase. Consequently, the procurement department included the complimentary items in the quantity stated on the PO. Risk Level: Low Risks and Impacts: - Ordering quantities exceeding the PR requirements may hinder the requestor's inventory management and potentially lead to unnecessary surplus inventory.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has improved the general procurement regulations by specifying the steps for purchasing goods with complimentary items.

- In the case of purchasing goods with complimentary items, the purchasing officer is required to issue a purchase order that specifies the quantity of the order along with the complimentary items and indicates "complimentary items" on the purchase order. Then, the purchase order must be printed and attached with the purchase requisition form and the quotation from the vendor before submitting it to the authorized person for approval.

- The monitoring revealed that from November 2022 to January 2023, the company issued purchase orders with the correct quantity of goods as requested by the requisitioner in the purchase requisition forms.

month/year Range2023-012024-01
• Observations from the Internal Control System Audit for Each Department in 2023 and Follow-up 4. Procurement, Expenses, and Payment: The company lacks documentation of reasons for selecting/procuring goods from specific vendors according to established guidelines. There is no evidence of vendor price comparisons for purchase/hiring orders exceeding 5,000 baht, which, according to operating procedures, require comparison from at least two vendors. Additionally, there is a lack of written explanation for selecting vendors who did not undergo the price comparison process as clearly defined in the guidelines. This is due to the use of specific procurement methods where there is only one vendor, thus no price comparison according to the established guidelines. Risk Level: Low Risks and Impacts: - The lack of clear justification and selection documentation may result in auditors and approvers receiving insufficient information for approval considerations. It also hinders the ability to review the appropriateness of operations in the future.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has improved the general procurement regulations by adding conditions and comparison procedures for selecting vendors. In the case of a single vendor, the selection is clearly stated in writing.

- The company prepares and updates the registry of goods with sole distributors to be used as a reference in the procurement process without price comparison. The company is required to evaluate and monitor the quality of vendors in the registry regularly twice a year.

- The monitoring found that from November 2022 to January 2023, the company specified the reasons for vendor selection before purchasing goods. In the case of goods with a single vendor, it was found that the items were listed in the registry of goods with sole distributors as per the specified guidelines.

month/year Range2023-012024-01
• Observations from the internal control system audit for each department within the company for the year 2023 and follow-up 5. Compliance with the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA): The company has established a "Privacy Notice." However, the PDPA working group is currently in the process of specifying detailed security measures for the collection, use, and disclosure of personal data for each department in writing. Risk Level: Low Risks and Impacts: - Failure to clearly specify security control measures, particularly for personal data, may result in insufficient tools for monitoring and controlling the security of personal data adequately.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company requires each department/division that processes personal data to collect and prepare a summary of security measures for the collection, use, or disclosure of personal data. These measures must cover access control to personal data, audit log procedures for systems storing personal data, data retention periods, and data deletion procedures.

- The audit found that the company had completed this process in November 2023, and the measures are being implemented.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant Observations with High and Medium Risk Levels Identified from the Internal Control System Audit for Each Department within the Company for the Year 2022 1. Procurement/Hiring, Expenses, and Payments: Approval and payment authorization should not be granted to individuals with direct family relationships. The audit found that the company has assigned the following authorization authorities: 1) Checks require joint signatures from two directors: the Chairman of the Executive Board and the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), who are immediate family members. 2) For bank transfers, the company has authorized the CEO as the sole approver. This may indicate that the company lacks sufficient checks and balances. Risk Level: Medium (Originally: High) Risks and Impacts: - The aforementioned situation presents a risk of authorizing payments for goods or services of high value and material significance to the business without joint consideration and approval from other authorized individuals.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has reviewed the issuance of checks or money transfers for goods or services to sellers, requiring at least two authorized signatories: 1) the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to co-sign with 2) the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or the Accounting and Finance Manager. The company has also reviewed and updated the authorization schedule, specifying the positions of authorized signatories. This has been submitted to the Board of Directors for approval in April 2023.

- The company has notified the bank of the change, with a waiting period for the completion of the process by each of the three banks. In the follow-up, it was found that from July to October 2023, the company signed checks and made bank transfers with at least two authorized signatories, who are not related or directly related, in accordance with the guidelines.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant High and Medium Risk Observations Identified from the Internal Control System Audit for Each Department within the Company for the Year 2022 2. Financial, Budgetary, and Cash Management: The company invests funds with financial institutions to achieve expected returns. However, there is no documented evidence of the decision-making process and approval for these investments. Additionally, there are no established criteria or requirements for selecting and evaluating financing options from various sources, including considerations for maximizing returns on surplus cash. Furthermore, the operational procedures and authorization processes for these transactions are not clearly defined in writing. Risk Level: Medium Risks and Impacts: - The lack of established criteria and operational procedures results in a lack of clear and standardized guidelines for employees. Management may not have sufficient information for decision-making, potentially leading to missed opportunities for the company to maximize benefits from these transactions.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has established an investment and liquidity management policy, including criteria for selecting investments when there is excess cash from operations, and has established written regulations for the investment of excess cash in August 2023.

- Monitoring found that from August to September 2023, the company complied with the established investment and liquidity management policies and operating procedures.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant Observations with High and Moderate Risk Levels Identified from the Internal Control System Audit for Each System within the Company for the Year 2022 3. Application Controls: Inappropriate restriction and control of user account privileges (USER ID) in the system. Risk Level: Low (Previously: High) Risks and Impacts: - There is a risk that unauthorized individuals may access information without proper authorization, potentially leading to damage to company data.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has instructed the IT department, in collaboration with the top management of each department, to review system access rights. Access rights are restricted to align with the duties and responsibilities of each position, subject to CEO approval before being forwarded to the IT department for system access adjustments according to the authorized rights.

- The company mandates a review of system access rights at least once a year.

- Monitoring revealed that the company has implemented continuous improvements from April to November 2023. The access rights table has been reviewed by the head of the department or the department manager and received written approval from the CEO. The IT department has updated the access rights to accurately reflect the authorized rights table.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant High and Medium Risk Observations Identified from the Internal Control System Audit for Each Department within the Company in 2022 4. General IT Controls: Password settings and configurations do not comply with the security policy. The company has established a regulation on "Data Access Control in the Work System," approved and effective from August 1, 2021. This regulation outlines essential practices for password settings, such as mandatory password changes upon initial receipt, a minimum length of 8 characters including special characters, etc. However, it was found that password structures were not set according to the regulations, and the IT department has not yet implemented sufficiently rigorous security checks to control data access within the work system. Risk Level: High Risks and Impacts: - May lead to unauthorized access to company data.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has instructed the IT department to review the regulations regarding data access control in the system and communicate them to relevant personnel for their understanding, with strict enforcement.

- The audit in July 2023 found that the company had set and enforced password policies and procedures in accordance with all established regulations. This includes setting the maximum number of allowed failed login attempts to 3, in full compliance with relevant regulations.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant High and Moderate Risk Observations Identified from the Internal Control System Review of Each Business Unit within the Company for 2022 5. Compliance with Key Regulations and Requirements: The Company has a Personal Data Protection Policy and has prepared consent forms for the collection, use, and disclosure of personal data (for employees) to obtain consent for the collection of employee data for employment contract verification and internal operations of the company and its external service providers regarding employment and benefits. However, the Company has not yet considered appointing a Data Protection Officer (DPO) and consolidating personal data from each department to create a Record of Processing Activities (ROPA) as a tool to help assess risks and define comprehensive relevant controls.
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company announced the appointment of the company's data protection officer by establishing a "Personal Data Protection Working Group (PDPA Working Group)" which is represented by each department of the company on May 2, 2022, and has established a written cookie policy. The cookie policy is communicated on the company's website, where website visitors can choose to set their consent to the use of cookies.

- The company collects personal data from each activity of each department that processes personal data into a record of processing activities (ROPA) to help identify and assess risks. It also includes establishing relevant control measures for each activity that collects, stores, uses, and discloses personal data completely.

- The monitoring found that the company collects personal data from each activity of each department, covering the main activities that the company currently operates. The company has established a standard form for data subjects to consent to the collection, use, disclosure, and processing of personal data through and prepares a "Consent Form" for use for specific marketing purposes and for employees who operate based on consent. In addition, the company has been found to inform employees and any person of the installation and use of the CCTV system by clearly displaying signs that can be read and understood appropriately.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
• Significant high and moderate risk observations identified from the internal control system audits of each department within the company for the year 2022. 6. Risk Management and Corporate Governance: The company is in the process of enhancing its corporate governance system to build confidence among all stakeholders. This encompasses various aspects such as business ethics, defining the authority and responsibilities of the Board of Directors and management, succession planning, strategic planning, enterprise risk management, business continuity, and anti-corruption measures. Risk Level: Low (previously: Moderate)
Incident no longer subject to action

- The company has continuously implemented good corporate governance systems in preparation for becoming a listed company. Therefore:

- Prepare self-assessment forms for the Board of Directors, subcommittees, and individuals to conduct self-assessments at least once a year in accordance with good corporate governance principles, and review and improve authorization procedures for executive-level operations.

- Establish a Risk Management Working Group by resolution of the 1/2023 Risk Management Committee meeting on March 9, 2023, consisting of representatives from each department/division to oversee and support the implementation of risk management within the organization in alignment with business objectives. However, there are still issues to be monitored in the 3rd quarter in preparation for becoming a listed company.

- Specify an email address: ac.commit@inspireivf.com To serve as a channel for receiving whistleblowing or complaints, and assign the company secretary to be responsible for collecting and reporting to the Board of Directors. The risk register has been improved by identifying risks at both the organizational and activity levels for all departments. Additionally, there is a follow-up and reporting of risk management results that occurred during July - September 2023 through the 3rd/2023 Risk Management Committee meeting on October 20, 2023. There is also a review to update potential emerging risks for further management. Furthermore, qualifications for successors to the positions of Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer have been defined.

- Establish channels for receiving complaints/grievances regarding unethical business conduct from external stakeholders.

- Review and improve upon previously implemented matters, such as: establishing a complete director registration and assigning responsibility for disclosing director information, establishing a complete succession plan for key executives, establishing a business plan, establishing a risk register and reporting risk management results to the Risk Management Committee and the Board of Directors, adding channels for receiving complaints or whistleblowing regarding misconduct/fraud or non-compliance with company policies from external stakeholders through the company's website.

- The company launched a new website in September 2024. This website discloses important information to stakeholders in accordance with the principles of good corporate governance for listed companies.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

Yes

Auditor's Observations

Report on Internal Control Audit and Other Matters from the Audit of Financial Statements

The company's auditor, Mr. Pot Asawasintrichai from Grin Audit Co., Ltd., who has been approved by the SEC, studied and evaluated the company's accounting and internal control systems over financial reporting. The objective was to determine the appropriate scope of audit work and audit procedures to express an opinion on the financial statements accurately. During the audit of the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2022, the auditor made recommendations regarding internal control over financial reporting and other matters. From the follow-up on these observations during the audit of the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2023, it was found that the company had successfully implemented corrective actions to address the observations or recommendations identified during the audit.

For the audit of the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2023 and As of December 31, 2023. Therefore, the auditor did not find any significant weaknesses in internal control over financial reporting and other matters that could materially affect the financial statements.


Summary of Observations or Recommendations from the Audit of the Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2022

1. Closing Accounts and Preparing Financial Statements

• The submission of accounting details and information was delayed beyond the agreed-upon schedule, and some submitted accounting information was not updated, resulting in discrepancies between the accounting data and the general ledger according to the accounting system during the audit.

Company's Actions

The company prepared and provided data to the auditor within the timeframe before the audit engagement. Some data was provided during the audit, which may have been affected by adjustments made during the audit, such as the analysis of revenue, cost of sales, and gross profit. Initially, the company would provide draft data to the auditor before the audit engagement. If there were any impacts from adjustments made during the audit, the company would immediately correct the data and provide the revised version to the auditor.

Follow-up

The company provided draft data to the auditor before the audit engagement. In cases where data was updated during the audit, the company immediately corrected and resubmitted the data to the auditor within the audit period.

• The company still made numerous adjustments in the general journal and general ledger during the audit.

Company's Actions

The company regularly records and verifies accounting data, reducing errors in accounting entries.

Follow-up

From the follow-up, it was found that the company had reduced the number of adjustments from 31 in 2022 to 12 in 2023.

• The company recorded accounting entries without attaching supporting documents or with incomplete documents from the beginning.

Company's Actions The company prepared supporting documents for adjustments in other formats, such as Excel files, which were provided to the auditor. However, the company has since attached the supporting documents in hard copy and submitted them to the auditor.

Follow-up

In 2023, from the follow-up by random testing, it was found that the company had attached all supporting documents in hard copy to the auditor.

2. Accounts Receivable System

• From the audit, it was found that the company did not use system data to plan the work procedures for reviewing and analyzing the aging of trade receivables, including the outstanding balance of each trade debtor at the end of the period, to consider outstanding balances, customer aging, debt collection, and allowance for doubtful accounts estimation in accordance with financial reporting standards, as well as reconciling the balances with the general ledger.

Company's Actions

In 2022, the company already conducted an aging analysis of trade receivables, including the outstanding balance of each trade receivable at the end of the period, to consider outstanding balances and customer aging for debt collection and allowance for doubtful accounts estimation in accordance with financial reporting standards, as well as reconciling the balances with the general ledger. This was done by exporting data from the system to prepare the analysis report. However, the company has contacted the system administrator to enable the generation of this report directly from the system.

Follow-up

In 2023, the company started preparing the report using the system, commencing from the financial statements for the year ended 2023.

3. Accounts Payable System

• From the audit, it was found that the company did not use system data to plan the work procedures for reviewing and analyzing the aging of trade accounts payable, including the outstanding balance of each trade creditor at the end of the period, to consider outstanding balances, creditor aging, the duration of outstanding creditors, and outstanding post-dated checks, as well as reconciling the balances with the general ledger.

Company's Actions

In 2022, the company already conducted an aging analysis of trade payables, including the outstanding balance of each trade creditor at the end of the period, to consider outstanding balances and creditor aging for debt monitoring and to reconcile the balances with the general ledger. This was done by exporting data from the system to prepare the analysis report. However, the company has contacted the system administrator to enable the generation of this report directly from the system.

Follow-up

In 2023, the company started preparing the report using the system, commencing from the financial statements for the year ended 2023.

4. Revenue System

• Some documents have a month indicated in the document number that does not match the month in the document date, such as invoice INV2203XXXX dated XX Apr 2022, etc.

• The company made changes to names, codes HN.no This was done by modifying the original invoice through the system to create a new invoice without canceling the previously issued invoice. Additionally, the newly printed invoice did not have the customer's signature or document preparation signature.

• Discrepancies were found between the entries in the receipt voucher and the general ledger due to modifications made to the original receipt voucher through the system to create a new receipt voucher without canceling the previously issued one. Additionally, the newly printed receipt voucher did not have the signatures of the document preparer, issuer, and verifier.

Company's Actions

1. Implement a period lock for the accounting period, with the CFO as the authorized user, to prevent backdating entries or making retrospective adjustments. In cases where adjustments are necessary and do not affect the financial figures that have already been closed, the company requires a written request to unlock the accounting period for correcting errors in the system.

2. Enforce the verification of the accuracy and completeness of signatures on accounting documents, especially for revised items that need to be reprinted, and ensure that the preparer, reviewer, and approver have signed completely.

Follow-up

In 2023, from the follow-up by random testing,

- No documents were found where the month indicated in the document number did not match the month in the document date.

- No documents with code HN.no Incorrect

- No discrepancies were found between the entries in the receipt voucher and the general ledger.

• Some invoices were not signed by customers.

Company's Actions

The reasons were: 1) Employee error, for which the company has established additional verification procedures, and 2) Foreign customers who had already returned to their home countries and were unable to sign the invoices. However, the company has other supporting documents to confirm revenue recognition, such as treatment records.

Follow-up

In 2023, from random checks, no invoices were found without customer signatures due to employee error. For foreign customers who were unable to sign the documents, the company attached service records from the system as supporting evidence to confirm service delivery, ensuring the reliability of the company's revenue recognition.

• From the audit, it was found that the company did not have a written policy regarding the criteria and conditions for granting customer discounts, including a database of which customers receive discounts and at what rates.

Company's Actions

The company has established written authorization for customer discounts.

Follow-up

In 2023, the company established the aforementioned policy, which was approved at the 3/2556 Board of Directors meeting on December 21, 2023. The CEO has also approved customer discounts.

• From the audit, it was found that the company had a significant number of adjustments related to revenue recognition. Most of these adjustments were due to revenue being recognized in the incorrect period, meaning the date of revenue recording did not match the date of work completion (service delivery according to the steps) as per the patient file/lab result documents. However, during the audit, the company made adjustments to bring them within the correct quarter, although they still did not align with the date of service delivery completion. The company believes that this does not have a material impact on the amounts in the financial statements.

Company's Actions

The company has prepared a revenue adjustment report to comply with the revenue recognition criteria under financial reporting standards, which is when the service is completed according to the steps. The report uses data from the system, processed by employees to calculate the value to be adjusted at the end of each month. The calculated adjustments are then recorded in the system. This adjustment report can be fully referenced.

Follow-up

In 2023, the company made improvements in accordance with normal accounting methods to record revenue accurately according to the period and only for the month in which the work was completed. No further issues were found.

• The company prepared accounting data for deferred revenue, showing the amortization of revenue from services rendered based on service delivery to customers. From the audit, it was found that the company could not reconcile the revenue from services recognized gradually from deferred revenue with the general ledger account for service revenue. This was because service revenue included both advance payments and non-advance payments, and the company did not clearly separate these in the service revenue report.

Company's Actions

The company has prepared an adjustment entry for deferred revenue to comply with the revenue recognition criteria under financial reporting standards, which is when the service is completed according to the steps. The report uses data from the system, processed by employees to calculate the value to be adjusted at the end of each month. The calculated adjustments are then recorded in the system. This adjustment report can be fully referenced.

Follow-up

In 2023, the company addressed the observation, and no further issues were found.

5. Inventory System

• When reconciling the inventory movement report (Stock Card) from the system, the value of inventory movement shown did not match the general ledger. However, during the audit, the company corrected the inventory movement (Stock Card) to show the correct balance according to the accounting records. The correction was done manually, and the inventory balance was adjusted to be correct in the financial statements.

• Goods were withdrawn but not deducted from the system's Stock Card report for the year 2022, resulting in a discrepancy between the ending balance in the Stock report as of December 31, 2022, and the beginning balance in the Stock Card report as of January 1, 2023. However, the company has made adjustments to these entries during the audit.

• The inventory movement report (Stock Card) from the system displayed the quantity in a mixed format of both small and large units. It did not clearly show the stock in a consistent unit of measure.

Company's Actions

From the investigation of the discrepancies, it was found that there were retrospective data corrections in the system without informing the accounting department. This resulted in discrepancies between the original data that had been closed and the Stock Card data after the correction. For cases where requisition documents were found without corresponding deductions in the Stock card, it was due to employee error in data entry. To address this issue, the company conducted internal training and assigned clear responsibility for inventory control to each department. They also implemented a period lock after the monthly closing process and established an approval process for data corrections to ensure traceability from June 2023 onwards. Additionally, they mandated the recording of inventory in the system using the smallest unit of measure for each item.

Follow-up in 2023

It was found that

- The balance of inventory movements from the system now matches the general ledger.

- No requisition documents were found without corresponding deductions in the Stock card. The method of recording inventory has been adjusted to consistently use the smallest unit of measure.

• From the audit, it was found that the company prepared the inventory aging analysis report from the STOCK LOT EXPIRE 31.12.65 report, which was prepared manually (Microsoft Excel) only. The system was not used, and no one was assigned to review the report.

Company's Actions

The company has implemented an inventory aging analysis report within the system since July 2023.

Follow-up

In 2023, it was found that the company had implemented an inventory aging analysis report within the system.

6. Expenses and Cost of Sales System

• From the audit, it was found that there were expenses that the company did not record in the correct period of service and had never been accrued during the period. During the audit, the company adjusted the expenses to be correct by quarter but did not adjust them to be correct by the month of service. The company believes that this does not have a material impact on the amounts in the financial statements.

Company's Actions

Previously, the company did not record certain expenses on an accrual basis but recognized them on the date the invoice was received from the service provider. The company has taken corrective action by improving the method of expense recognition to an accrual basis. They have implemented a control account to track actual expenses incurred based on the portion of service used, ensuring accurate and complete expense recording within the accounting period.

Follow-up

In 2023, it was found that the company recognized expenses on an accrual basis.

• From the audit, it was found that the company did not follow the internal control procedures. Random checks revealed that Purchase Requisitions (PR) and Purchase Orders (PO) were prepared with dates on the PR and PO documents after the date the invoice was received.

Company's Actions

The cause stemmed from miscommunication between the purchasing officer and the supplier regarding order confirmation and invoice issuance. This has been addressed by establishing a procedure for the purchasing officer to coordinate with the supplier to issue invoices only after receiving purchase orders from the company. This procedure has been in effect since September 2023.

Follow-up

In 2023, from random checks, it was found that there were 6 items with Purchase Requisitions and Purchase Orders prepared after the invoice date. This was because the vendor had issued invoices since being contacted by the company in May-August, which occurred before the improvement of the company's work process.

• For receiving documents of the same type of goods and from the same vendor within a close timeframe, it was found that the receiving documents showed different unit prices, with some including VAT and others excluding VAT. This differed from the Stock card, which recorded the receipt of goods at the price including VAT from both types of receiving documents.

Company's Actions

The cause stemmed from the lack of clear guidelines for employees. The company has since established clear guidelines, provided training to relevant employees, and adjusted the method of recording goods receipts to reflect the value stated on the invoices received from suppliers.

Follow-up

In 2023, no discrepancies were found in the receiving documents from random checks.

• In cases where the company received free items with purchased goods, some receiving documents did not show the price/unit allocation for the free items. Meanwhile, the Stock card showed the receipt of goods according to the same receiving document with the price allocated to the total quantity including the free items. This resulted in some items having different unit prices between the receiving document and the Stock card.

Company's Actions

The cause stemmed from the lack of clear guidelines for employees. The company has since established clear guidelines, provided training to relevant employees, and adjusted the method of recording goods receipts to include the allocation of prices for free items.

Follow-up

In 2023, this issue was not found during random checks.

7. Payroll System

• From the audit, it was found that the company prepared payroll reports using Microsoft Excel, resulting in errors in payroll accruals between payroll reports and the general ledger. In addition, errors were found in the allocation of cost center expenses for payroll according to the cost plan. Expenses for sales and administration were incorrect. However, the company has made adjustments to the entries during the audit.

Company's Actions

The cause stemmed from unclear role definitions for each job function, leading to misclassification of payroll-related expenses. Currently, the company has implemented corrective actions by establishing clear guidelines and providing training to relevant employees. They also perform monthly reconciliations of calculated payroll expenses with accounting records, both in terms of value and cost center allocation, to ensure accuracy and proper classification in the financial statements.

Follow-up

In 2023, no observations of incorrect payroll classification were found.

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of Unique Advisor Limited as the Company's internal auditor and has appointed Mr. Kosol Yemleamul as the Head of Internal Audit, deeming that he has sufficient qualifications, experience, and training to perform the duties of the Company's internal auditor, as well as independence in performing the work to audit and assess the adequacy of the internal control system and compliance with the Company's system. The internal auditor has coordinated with personnel from all departments of the Company, monitored the improvement of the internal control system to comply with the recommendations of the internal auditor, including preparing an internal control assessment and audit report, and presenting the report to the Audit Committee meetings directly on a regular basis. (Details regarding the qualifications of the Head of Internal Audit are provided in Appendix 3 "Details of the Company's Head of Internal Audit".)

Within the scope of authority, duties, and responsibilities of the Audit Committee, the Audit Committee has the authority, in conjunction with the management, to evaluate the performance and consider the merits and demerits, removal, transfer, or termination of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The Company has appointed Unique Advisor Co., Ltd. (“Internal Auditor”) as the internal auditor, which provides advice on appropriate internal control systems and continuously monitors improvements. The appointment of the Internal Auditor was approved by the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 3/2565 on October 28, 2022, and the latest appointment was made at the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2567 on February 26, 2023, with a scope of work from the first quarter of 2023 to the fourth quarter of 2023. The Board of Directors has considered the qualifications of Unique Advisor Co., Ltd. and Mr. Kosol Yemleemoon (qualifications of the Head of Internal Audit are shown in Appendix 3 "Details of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company"), and is of the opinion that Unique Advisor Co., Ltd. and the person in charge of the operation are qualified to review and assess the adequacy of the Company's internal control system and report the results to the Board of Directors. The scope of the internal control system audit covers a total of 12 systems as follows:

1. Revenue from Sales and Services

2. Laboratory Management and Inventory Management

3. Procurement/Hiring, Expenses, and Disbursements

4. Fixed Asset Management and Maintenance

5. Human Resources Management

6. Financial Management, Budgeting, and Cash Management

7. Closing Accounts and Financial Statement Preparation

8. IT General Controls

9. Application Controls

10. Related Party Transactions

11. Compliance with Laws and Regulations

12. Enterprise Risk Management and Good Corporate Governance

The Internal Audit has assessed the overall internal control system for 2022 once and conducted four additional audits to ensure that the Company has effectively implemented the internal control system and taken actions to improve and correct the recommendations from the internal control system assessment for 2022. In 2023, the Internal Audit audited the internal control system twice and conducted one follow-up audit to monitor the improvements and corrections made based on the recommendations from the internal control system audit for 2023. For 2024, the Internal Audit has audited the internal control system three times and submitted a total of eight reports on the results of the internal control system audit to the Audit Committee at the Audit Committee meetings.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Chanachai JoonjirapornPerson

- IServing as a director and holding the position Chairman of the Executive Committee and authorized director of the company.

- The company's major shareholder, Mr. Chanachai Joonjiraporn, holds 35.76 percent of the registered paid capital as of December 31, 2024.

2024-12-31T00:00
Miss Kasinee KuldilokePerson

- Serving as a director and holding the position of Chief Executive Officer and an authorized signatory of the company.

- Shareholder of the company, with Ms. Kasinee Kuldiloke holding 6.48 percent of the registered and paid-up capital as of December 31, 1974.

2024-12-31T00:00
Naphapak PreechanonPerson

- The younger sister of Ms. Kasinee Kuldiloke who is the Director, Chief Executive Officer, authorized signatory of the company, and shareholder of the company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Santa SrisuparpPerson

- Executive Director and Chief Medical and Nursing Officer of Inspire IVF Public Company Limited

2024-12-31T00:00
I-Studio-D Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonProvides architectural, landscape architecture, interior design, and engineering services.

- The director and authorized director of i-Studio-D Company Limited is Mr. Thitiwat Juljirabhongkul.

- Mr. Thitiwat Joonjiraporn is a shareholder of Inspire IVF Public Company Limited holding 1.83 percent of the registered and paid-up capital as of December 31, 2024.

- The juristic person is held by the shareholders of I-STUDIOS-D LIMITED as of September 30, 2024, as follows:

- Mr. Thitiwat Juljirabhongkul holds 60 percent of the registered and paid-up capital.

- Mr. Pisit Juljirabhongkul holds 20 percent of the registered and paid-up capital.

- Ms. Lalin Ramyamonthon holds 20 percent of the registered and paid-up capital.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
0.0 · Necessity: The Company obtained an unsecured, interest-free loan from Mr. Chanachai Joonjiraporn for use as working capital. As of December 31, 2021 and December 31, 2022, the outstanding balance was 11.87 million baht. There were no additional loans granted in 2023. A formal agreement was established for this loan. The Company fully repaid the loan on May 10, 2023. Moving forward, the Company's policy is to secure sufficient funding for its operations without relying on loans from related parties. However, if the Company requires financial assistance from related parties, it will comply with relevant regulations and ensure full disclosure. · Description: The company borrowed money from Mr. Chanachai Joonjiraporn. - Balance as of the end of the period · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: List of Financial Aid and Liabilities with Financial Institutions · Audit committee opinion: The Company received financial assistance from its shareholders, which included loans for working capital, advances for pharmaceutical and medical supply purchases, and salary advances for employees. These measures were taken due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which temporarily affected the Company's liquidity. These transactions were deemed necessary and in the best interest of the Company. The Company fully repaid all loans in 2023. Going forward, the Company's policy is to secure sufficient funding for its business operations without relying on financial assistance from directors or shareholders. · As of year before yesteryear: 11.87 · 0.0 · Necessity: At the end of 2021, the Company adjusted its asset register by writing off assets worth 2.59 million baht at cost. These assets lacked reliable supporting documentation for accounting records and were deducted from the balance of loans from directors/major shareholders. Despite the adjustment, the Company continues to utilize these assets. Most of the assets owned by directors/major shareholders and used by the Company are not essential to the core business operations, such as furniture and decorations, and are immaterial in value. The directors/major shareholders have granted the Company permission to continue using these assets free of charge. However, the Company will be responsible for any dismantling costs. · Description: The company utilizes the assets of its directors (major shareholders) in conducting business. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The use of assets from directors arose from the fact that in the past, the Company did not have a clear policy on asset registration and accounting. Subsequently, the Company has improved its asset register and accounting records and has written off assets for which reliable supporting documentation could not be found. The assets that the Company continues to use are mainly furniture and decorations, which are not assets used in the main business and are not material in value. Therefore, it is not considered a reliance on major assets used in the business from directors/major shareholders. These transactions are therefore considered necessary and in the best interests of the Company. In addition to the aforementioned historical transactions, the Company has procured assets used in its business without using assets owned by directors/shareholders. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.0 · Necessity: In May 2023, the company entered into a hire purchase agreement for an ultrasound machine valued at 1.08 million baht. Ms. Kasinee Kuldilok acted as the guarantor for the agreement, which spans a period of 3 years, from May 2023 to May 2026. No remuneration was involved in this arrangement. · Description: Ms. Kasinee Kuldiloke acted as a guarantor for the company. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: List of Financial Aid and Liabilities with Financial Institutions · Audit committee opinion: This list arises from the necessity of the company's business operations. The financial institution's requirement for directors to guarantee the credit line is a standard condition. The company does not incur any expenses for the directors' guarantees. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 4000.0 · Necessity: In 2020, Ms. Kasinee Kuladiloke utilized the fertility preservation services, a regular business offering of the company. Following the establishment of the related party transaction policy in October 2023, the aforementioned director settled the service fees with the company. The charged rate was comparable to that offered to other customers. Ms. Kasinee's utilization of the fertility preservation services amounted to 4,000 baht per year. She settled the fees for the years 2021 and 2022 in 2023, totaling 8,000 baht. In 2024, she paid 4,000 baht, consistent with the standard service fee offered to other clients. · Description: Fertility preservation services · As of yesteryear: 4000.0 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The Company provided services to Miss Kasinee Kuladiloke in accordance with the Company's normal course of business, with consideration comparable to that of other customers. This transaction arose from the Company's ordinary business operations, with prices and commercial terms consistent with normal business practices. Therefore, it is a transaction that occurred out of necessity, is reasonable, and has comparable prices and commercial terms to transactions with the general public. · As of year before yesteryear: 8000.0
0.0 · Necessity: In 2023, Ms. Naphak Prechanon, sister of Ms. Kasinee Gundilok, referred clients to the company. In accordance with the company's referral program and commission rates, Ms. Naphak received a referral fee of 20,300 Baht. This transaction was conducted as part of normal business operations and under the same terms and conditions as those applicable to external parties. No contract renewal is offered upon expiration. · Description: Suggested Value · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The company has a clear and documented policy on appointing and compensating customer referral agents. The payment made to Ms. Naphak Preechanon is a transaction that arose from the company's normal business operations. The price and commercial terms are in line with normal business practices. Therefore, the transaction was necessary, reasonable, and had comparable prices and commercial terms to transactions with the general public. However, the company did not renew the agreement upon its expiration. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: In 2023, Ms. Naphak Preechanon received preventive and rehabilitative medical services from the company. She paid a total of 505,000 baht, which is a comparable service rate to other customers. · Description: Anti-aging medicine · As of yesteryear: 0.51 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The Company provided services to Nang Naphak Preechanon in accordance with the Company's normal course of business, with prices and commercial terms consistent with normal business practices. Therefore, the transactions were necessary, reasonable, and had comparable prices and commercial terms to transactions with the general public. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.92 · Necessity: The Company paid professional fees in addition to monthly salaries to Dr. Santa Srisupab for egg collection services and embryo transfer services. The fees in 2021, 2022, 2023, and the first nine months of 2024 were 0.14 million baht, 1.12 million baht, 0.76 million baht, and 0.70 million baht, respectively. These fees were paid at the rate specified in the professional fee structure policy approved by the Company's Board of Directors. · Description: Medical professional fees · As of yesteryear: 0.76 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The professional fees of Dr. Santa Srisuparp are paid in accordance with the company's professional fee structure policy. Therefore, the professional fees paid by the company to Dr. Santa Srisupap are considered appropriate and in line with the company's policy. The determination of these fees takes into account the doctor's experience, the procedures involved in providing the service, the costs associated with service provision, and the fee rates of other providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.12
0.06 · Necessity: In 2023, the Company hired I-Studio-D Co., Ltd. to renovate and repair the nurse's room, laboratory, and office due to damage to the original space, at an approximate cost of 1.07 million baht. The Company also hired them to repair office equipment, such as tables and sinks, at an approximate cost of 0.02 million baht. During the first nine months of 2024, the Company repaired the grease trap water pump, valve sets, and installed partitions for the Human Resources Department at an approximate cost of 60,000 baht. These expenses are incurred from the Company's normal business operations. In carrying out these transactions, the Company compared prices and followed the Company's general procurement procedures, with I-Studio-D Co., Ltd. offering the lowest price. · Description: The company hired I-Studio-D Co., Ltd. to build an extension to the office. · As of yesteryear: 1.09 · Nature of transaction: Normal Business Service List and Normal Business Support List · Audit committee opinion: The company has hired I-Studio-D Co., Ltd., a company whose shareholders include Mr. Thitiwat Junjirapornkul, to renovate and repair the infirmary, laboratory, and office due to damage to the original space, as well as to repair various equipment. This transaction arises from the company's normal course of business. The company has compared prices and complied with the company's general procurement procedures. Therefore, this transaction is necessary, reasonable, and has been compared in terms of price and trading conditions with transactions with the general public according to the specified regulations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Company has established a policy and guidelines for entering into transactions with related parties, which was approved by the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 3/2022 on October 28, 2022, and No. 3/2023 on December 21, 2023. If the Company needs to enter into transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest or have an interest, the Company has established criteria and procedures for approving connected transactions and transactions relating to the acquisition or disposal of the Company's assets to comply with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), as well as relevant laws, as follows:

1) Ordinary course of business transactions and transactions supporting the ordinary course of business. Such transactions must be conducted on normal commercial terms and at a fair price and must not result in a transfer of benefits comparable to transactions between the Company and the general public, or transactions between persons who may have conflicts of interest with the general public, or transactions of a similar nature with other operators in the same industry. The Company has a policy for the Board of Directors to consider and provide opinions on the reasons and necessity for such transactions on a quarterly basis and will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions.

2) Other transactions apart from the ordinary course of business and transactions supporting the ordinary course of business as mentioned above, such as property lease transactions, asset trading transactions, or financial assistance, the Company's policy is to have the Board of Directors consider and provide opinions on the reasons and necessity for such transactions. The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of the Company's significant assets. The Company has a policy of not lending money to persons who may have conflicts of interest to conduct business or operate on behalf of the Company. To ensure that the decision to enter into such transactions does not create conflicts of interest and is in the best interests of all shareholders, the Company will disclose such transactions in the Company's Annual Information Form and the Notes to the Financial Statements audited by the Company's auditor.

3) The Company will disclose such transactions in accordance with the criteria and procedures specified by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

4) All directors must comply with Section 88 of the Public Limited Companies Act B.E. 2535, which requires directors to notify the Company without delay in the following cases:

4.1) Having a direct or indirect interest in any contract made by the Company during the accounting period, stating the facts about the nature of the contract, the name of the other party to the contract, and the director's interest in the contract (if any).

4.2) Holding shares or debentures in the Company and its subsidiaries, stating the total amount increased or decreased during the accounting period (if any).

The Company will arrange for major shareholders, directors, and executives to submit information on their related persons to the company secretary's office, including every time there is a change to comply with the practice of controlling transactions with major shareholders, directors, executives, or persons related to such persons.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

The company anticipates that in the future, there may still be related party transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest with the company. Any related party transactions that occur will be those that are necessary and beneficial to the company. By

Financial assistance from the company's major shareholders will only be sought when necessary for business operations. The company has a policy to independently secure sufficient capital for its operations. After the company is listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the company will primarily utilize capital raised from the initial public offering and loans from financial institutions for its business operations, eliminating the need to seek financial assistance from shareholders. In the event that the company requires capital expenditure or working capital for business operations, the company will first endeavor to secure sufficient funding from equity and borrowings from external sources. If borrowing from related parties becomes necessary, the company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the SEC Office and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. Regarding loan guarantees by the Board of Directors and shareholders, the Board of Directors believes that it is no longer necessary. The company will negotiate with financial institutions regarding these conditions after the company is listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand.

For ordinary course of business transactions and transactions in support of ordinary business with general commercial terms, the company will implement measures to control related party transactions. These measures will adhere to the principles approved by the Board of Directors, as stipulated in the Securities and Exchange Act, and will ensure strict compliance with mutually agreed upon contracts. The pricing and terms of various transactions will be clearly defined, fair, and will not result in the transfer of benefits. In the event of related party transactions that require the opinion of the Audit Committee in accordance with the rules, regulations, and requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand regarding related party transactions, the company will request the Audit Committee's opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of such transactions.

Contents